Tidligere oppgjør
- Lørdag, 11. mai 2024, 23:30Major League Soccer 2024Toronto FC2-3New York City FC
- Lørdag, 16. mars 2024, 23:30Major League Soccer 2024New York City FC2-1Toronto FC
- Søndag, 24. september 2023, 17:00Major League Soccer 2023New York City FC3-0Toronto FC
- Onsdag, 26. juli 2023, 23:30Leagues Cup 2023New York City FC5-0Toronto FC
- Lørdag, 29. april 2023, 23:30Major League Soccer 2023Toronto FC1-0New York City FC
- Søndag, 24. april 2022, 21:00Major League Soccer 2022New York City FC5-4Toronto FC
- Lørdag, 2. april 2022, 20:00Major League Soccer 2022Toronto FC2-1New York City FC
- Søndag, 8. august 2021, 00:00Major League Soccer 2021Toronto FC2-2New York City FC
- Lørdag, 15. mai 2021, 17:00Major League Soccer 2021New York City FC1-1Toronto FC
- Onsdag, 28. oktober 2020, 23:30Major League Soccer 2020Toronto FC0-1New York City FC
- Onsdag, 23. september 2020, 23:00Major League Soccer 2020New York City FC0-1Toronto FC
- Mandag, 27. juli 2020, 00:30Major League Soccer 2020Toronto FC1-3New York City FC
- Lørdag, 7. mars 2020, 22:00Major League Soccer 2020Toronto FC1-0New York City FC
- Onsdag, 23. oktober 2019, 23:00Major League Soccer 2019New York City FC1-2Toronto FC
- Onsdag, 11. september 2019, 23:00Major League Soccer 2019New York City FC1-1Toronto FC
- Lørdag, 30. mars 2019, 00:00Major League Soccer 2019Toronto FC4-0New York City FC
- Søndag, 12. august 2018, 20:00Major League Soccer 2018Toronto FC2-3New York City FC
- Søndag, 24. juni 2018, 21:00Major League Soccer 2018New York City FC2-1Toronto FC
- Søndag, 30. juli 2017, 18:00Major League Soccer 2017Toronto FC4-0New York City FC
- Onsdag, 19. juli 2017, 23:30Major League Soccer 2017New York City FC2-2Toronto FC
- Søndag, 6. november 2016, 23:30Major League Soccer 2016New York City FC0-5Toronto FC
- Søndag, 30. oktober 2016, 23:00Major League Soccer 2016Toronto FC2-0New York City FC
- Onsdag, 18. mai 2016, 23:00Major League Soccer 2016Toronto FC1-1New York City FC
- Søndag, 13. mars 2016, 21:00Major League Soccer 2016New York City FC2-2Toronto FC
- Onsdag, 16. september 2015, 23:30Major League Soccer 2015New York City FC2-0Toronto FC
- Søndag, 12. juli 2015, 19:00Major League Soccer 2015New York City FC4-4Toronto FC
- Lørdag, 20. juni 2015, 23:00Major League Soccer 2015Toronto FC0-2New York City FC